2 Jan 2019

The imputation of "madness" is an Ad Hominem attack

The imputation of "madness" is an Ad Hominem attack.

Calling someone "mad" is meaningless abuse.

Saying you disagree with someone because they are "mad" is the same as saying you disagree with someone because (you think) they are a scoundrel.

In other words it is an argumentum ad hominem.


In fact "scoundrel" in this context has potentially more meaning than "mad".

Calling someone a "Scoundrel" means someone the speaker regards as morally questionable in some way.

Calling someone "Madman" ultimately means nothing more than that the speaker disagrees with them.