"Churchill was a white supremacist mass murderer."
This is simply not true.
If Churchill was TRULY and ESSENTIALLY a white supremacist mass murderer then he would have admired everything Hitler did rather then morally and implacably opposing Hitler, his regime and his crimes and making this the defining cause of his life.
Attentive investigative historians, Indians, Iraqis etc. might have more to say.
Churchill may have said things that were indicative of white supremacist views of a kind, but he wasn't primarily or predominantly a white supremacist. He was a democrat.
Similarly he may have been involved in policies in India or Mesopotamia that involved what could be called "mass murder" but this was not always as deliberate as the phrase implies. I don't believe that he was intentionally, primarily or predominantly a mass murderer.
It is absolutely vital that anything that could be called white supremacist about Churchill should be investigated and brought to light. But I think it will be found that to characterize him as a white supremacist without qualification is not wholly accurate.
It is also absolutely vital to investigate and be open about anything that could be called mass murder that Churchill may have been involved in. I think it is safe to say that Churchill was never involved in deliberate acts of mass murder.
We should learn from anything that indicates that he may have been in any way a white supremacist or a mass murderer.
Hence the statement is important and should be tolerated and accepted.
It is important that we do not see any actor in history as always totally and wholly morally pure and perfect and other actors in history as wholly morally bankrupt.
But I think that calling Churchill a "white supremacist mass murderer" diminishes the standing of what he said he stood for and what he did genuinely stand for - democracy and opposition to tyranny.
There is yet more to be said of course.
......................................
This is simply not true.
If Churchill was TRULY and ESSENTIALLY a white supremacist mass murderer then he would have admired everything Hitler did rather then morally and implacably opposing Hitler, his regime and his crimes and making this the defining cause of his life.
Attentive investigative historians, Indians, Iraqis etc. might have more to say.
Churchill may have said things that were indicative of white supremacist views of a kind, but he wasn't primarily or predominantly a white supremacist. He was a democrat.
Similarly he may have been involved in policies in India or Mesopotamia that involved what could be called "mass murder" but this was not always as deliberate as the phrase implies. I don't believe that he was intentionally, primarily or predominantly a mass murderer.
It is absolutely vital that anything that could be called white supremacist about Churchill should be investigated and brought to light. But I think it will be found that to characterize him as a white supremacist without qualification is not wholly accurate.
It is also absolutely vital to investigate and be open about anything that could be called mass murder that Churchill may have been involved in. I think it is safe to say that Churchill was never involved in deliberate acts of mass murder.
We should learn from anything that indicates that he may have been in any way a white supremacist or a mass murderer.
Hence the statement is important and should be tolerated and accepted.
It is important that we do not see any actor in history as always totally and wholly morally pure and perfect and other actors in history as wholly morally bankrupt.
But I think that calling Churchill a "white supremacist mass murderer" diminishes the standing of what he said he stood for and what he did genuinely stand for - democracy and opposition to tyranny.
There is yet more to be said of course.
......................................