For both Eric Hobsbawm - the Marxist, and for Thomas Szasz - the anti-Marxist libertarian, anarchist thought seems to have effectively not existed.
They both seem to deliberately disregard the entire body of anarchist thought and activism that was a long and lively tradition during the lifetimes of both these great and eminent thinkers.
Anarchism seems to have not been seen by either thinker as worthy of serious consideration.
Ironically Szasz's position is effectively very close to anarchism and certainly has clear affinities with it.
Hobsbawm's disdain for anarchism was a misjudgement in my view. He did in fact state that he didn't reallly take it seriously. Though of course it was while he was alive understandably a tendency that was almost as widespread as Marxism and still is today.
I personally see anarchism as practically the same thing as libertarianism- by which I mean devotion to individal freedom - though more doctrinnaire anarchists would diverge from this.
......
They both seem to deliberately disregard the entire body of anarchist thought and activism that was a long and lively tradition during the lifetimes of both these great and eminent thinkers.
Anarchism seems to have not been seen by either thinker as worthy of serious consideration.
Ironically Szasz's position is effectively very close to anarchism and certainly has clear affinities with it.
Hobsbawm's disdain for anarchism was a misjudgement in my view. He did in fact state that he didn't reallly take it seriously. Though of course it was while he was alive understandably a tendency that was almost as widespread as Marxism and still is today.
I personally see anarchism as practically the same thing as libertarianism- by which I mean devotion to individal freedom - though more doctrinnaire anarchists would diverge from this.
......