22 Mar 2018

"The bewitchment of our intelligence by language."

















The widespread belief in "Mental Health" and "Mental Ilness" is an example of just such a
"bewitchment of our intelligence by language."

We think that language mirrors reality - "the picture theory of language".
 But as Wittgenstein came to see - this is not always the case.
In the case of "Mental Illness" and "Mental Health" we think that these terms
 denote real entities - but they don't and can't. One reason that they can't
mean anything is that they are "Category Errors" - a concept described by another
 analytic philosopher Gilbert Ryle. To make things simple - only physical,
biological entities can have illnesses and be healthy.

 The mind is not a physical entity but a conceptual entity.
Hence "Mental Illness" and "mental health" are metaphors not realities.
They may be helpful metaphors but we should not mistake them for realities.

I don't deny that the mind is effectively entirely determined by the brain.
I am a materialist. But by "mind" I simply mean a concept.
But the only kind of illness that there can be is a physical one.

"The discovery that all mental diseases are brain diseases would mean the disappearance of psychiatry into neurology."
Thomas Szasz.