On "Punishment."
The philosopher Ted Honderich is very sceptical of the concept of punishment.
I think it is certainly very hard to argue for it as being anything other than revenge.
Isn't some form of revenge in a way repeating the original offence?
I believe in justice as a general concept. Justice not vengeance.
I prefer ideas of penance and repentance, though I would stress that I am an atheist.