24 Mar 2018

Lies of our times.

                   The mural by "Mear One" that Jeremy Corbyn recently expressed support for was not anti-Semitic. Since when does anti-capitalist mean anti-Semitic? Many Jews were and are anti-capitalists. But this kind of thing has been going on for quite a while. For example, I am quite certain that Ken Livingstone has never said anything anti-Semitic.

                  The mural concerned contained no "classic anti-Semitic images" at all. To say that this mural was anti-Semitic is basically a lie. Corbyn compared the mural's censorship to the censorship of murals by the great anti-capitalist Mexican artist Diego Rivera. The mural concerned is indeed comparable to the work of Rivera. And its censorship is indeed comparable to the censorship of Rivera's art. An irony is that Rivera - a descendant of conversos - once said, "My Jewishness is the dominant element in my life." (As someone who is also of converso ancestry, I can relate to the obesession that this identity can potentially engender).
                 
                   Once a right-wing campaign of condemnation, hysteria and hatred has been waged it is hard to argue against it. A right wing populist media-fuelled agenda has generated an idea based on a lie - a  "meme" of a kind - that is hard to counteract. Its simple purpose is to discredit the left by portraying it as beyond the pale since it is supposedly and allegedly in some way intrinsically anti-Jewish.

                 This is using the "smearing" tactics of fascism in the service of right-wing neoliberalism and populism. The right-wing of the Labour Party is fully in service of this meme. I believe that New Labour's support of the assault on Iraq under Tony Blair brought it close to fascism as it perpetrated a genocide on Iraq. The extent to which they despise the left in general is hard to fathom and the fanaticism and herd mentality they can show in following this up is quite unbelievable. I don't think it is because they greatly support the State of Israel that some of New Labour are behaving like this. I think one reason is related to the fact that they supported the genocide against Iraq and see an easy way of demonising the left that opposed the genocide against Iraq. As I have said elsewhere, I believe that the genocide against Iraq was itself anti-Semitic (in an admittedly unconventional sense of the term).

                It is similar to the hysterical campaign of disdain towards Oxfam and then other aid agencies led by the right-wing press in the UK - particularly by The Times and The Daily Mail - and then echoed by all of the media - that deceitfully and in the name of propriety simply seeks to discredit a culture of aid and assistance to the developing world. The aim of the discrediting of Oxfam and other aid agencies is to characterize such aid and assistance - both financial and practical - as "left wing" rather than humanitarian, and hence as suspect and questionable. It further seeks to change government policy with regard to the proportion of GDP given as aid to the developing world.

               Once again it is very hard to counteract this media narrative or media "meme". An Oxfam executive that complained in what was seen as an excessive manner about the vilification of his organization was forced to withdraw his comment. His comment was fully warranted given the ridiculously excessive vilification that Oxfam indeed faced, which was indeed totally unjustified given the small amount of wrong-doing the organization may have been responsible for. And yet the right-wing hysteria - that had extended its way to politicians of all hues - meant that he had to withdraw the comment.

              I think that many people see through such lies of our times. And I think that exposing such lies and pointing out that the "emperor is wearing no clothes" is not futile. To fully surrender to such lies - which is clearly what is happening with depressing predictability - is to succumb to an Orwellian nightmare and to surrender to the right-wing narrative in general.
              I think that the left of the Labour Party can only gain by resisting such lies. But most of all it would gain by fully and consistently and continuously renouncing and condemning the anti-Semitic genocide against Iraq and the crimes of Blair. Very few people in England were convinced by the wars that Blair waged in Iraq and Afghanistan, and his legacy is in tatters because of the unnecessary wars he waged. There is plenty of popularity to be gained by renouncing Blair. But I don't see this happening.

              I personally am a Green and may even vote Green, even in our unfair electoral system. The Labour Party is fundamentally a party of the past, and I see the Green Party and green ideology in general as the future for left wing politics. Though I voted Leave, I feel the Green Party is the right force for campaigning for the democratization of the E.U. - even if - and it is probably a question of when - we leave it.

                   But the Green Party is of course tiny compared to the Labour Party at present. I hope this changes. "Cultural Lag" means that it may take some time. In the meantime I hope the Labour Party moves further into the Green, as much as any further to the left.

(March 25th 2018).