5 Apr 2013

Reply to Gorgeous George


Galloway continues to maintain his comment related below.

In relation to the comment "I don't debate with Israelis" which he has not withdrawn, he said "I am not anti-semitic".

I would prefer him to say: "I am not anti-Jewish". If that is what he meant.

I personally have massive problems with the terminology "Anti-Semitic" in itself.
It was invented in the 19th century in Germany. It should no longer refer to anti-Jewish feeling IMO.
But that is a longer discussion.

Most people know that Jews and Israelis aren't necessarily the same thing.
For example, some people call themselves "Israeli Arabs".

He also said something like: "The Jews are a religion. And as an anti-racist I support them." Absurd.

The Jews are a people. I suggest George should read "A History of the Jews" by Paul Johnson.

The first sentence of which is:

"The Jews are the most tenacious people in history."

I respect George Galloway and his Respect Party - however he does need to be challenged by someone on things like this.

He has every right to be controversial and call for a boycott of the State of Israel etc. and compare it to apartheid South Africa. Yet he must be challenged on what I think are his conceptual mistakes.

The three societies or situations: South Africa, Ireland and Israel/Palestine are indeed all very comparable.

I think the South African solution is perhaps a pointer to the solution for the other two beleaguered places : ONE SOCIETY in some way!

...........