Talking of "Inappropriate Behaviour" -
is this an "Inappropriate Comment"? -
"I don't debate [with] Israelis", George Galloway.
Ahem.
Israelis are humans.
This comment is absurd. You may as well have said
"I don't debate Uzbekistanis".
You could conceivably say "I don't debate PEOPLE who call themselves "Israelis"." Possibly.
Tho that is a bit silly too of course.
What he objects to is the State of Israel - as do some Jews.
But what he said sounded - let's say - silly.
I hope good old George - who I like a great deal - has the guts to withdraw that comment made in an understandable moment of stupidity.
Possibly similar to the attention-grabbing stupid comment regarding raping sleeping women or whatever it was.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the Jews are a people with a right to SELF-DETERMINATION.
It is slightly annoying - let's say - that the EU and people from Europe in general tell Israel what do to - the representatives of a continent that nearly destroyed the Jewish people.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RE: TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
Good lefty saintly Irish and Scots folk like Galloway, some people at the UN, The Hallidays (Denis and Fred R.I.P.), Sine'ad O'Connor - saint that she is, Sea'n McBride R.I.P. USUALLY criticize (the State of) Israel for things like the Palestinian Nakbah, massacres, settlements, wars etc. Fair enough.
What annoys me is that they are often ALSO Irish Republicans. After all, Ireland is a republic.
The POINT is IRISH REPUBLICANISM obviously involves the concept in some way of TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
And yet this is forgotten and goes out of the window when it comes to Israel - where territorial integrity is probably a PRACTICAL NECESSITY apart from many other factors!
It SEEMS like pure hyprocrisy!
To pinpoint further my meaning - they seem to be saying something like :
The "Irish" have a right to the whole of "Ireland" BUT "the Jews" don't have a right to the whole of "Israel".
===================================================
I saw the monument below in Dublin almost exactly 20 years ago in about April 1993.
Among other things, I thought "Wow! That's a bit pro-IRA!"
Yet of course the man who composed the words did so decades before the IRA came into existence.
..................................................
In the case of Ireland the statement below is often regarded as wholly laudable.
Perhaps one reason being Ireland's suffering from imperialism.
In the case of Israel, perhaps they would not be regarded with the same approval were they about the Jewish people.
One reason is ignorance. Because it could perhaps be understandably believed that the words below apply a fortiori to the Jews.
My reaction to this monument at the age of 20 was on balance positive as I saw this as a question of justice and self-determination. It also is about uniting the people as equals rather than any territory.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Still it should cause us to pause and think again about the quasi-religion of nationalism.
Can you have "good nationalism" and "bad nationalism"?....
The words mention Ireland only once. If you are any kind of nationalist, apply them to your "Nation" by replacing its name with "Ireland" and then see how you feel about it. Very interesting anyway!
For example replace the word "Ireland's" with the word "Israel's" and for some reason the quote would suddenly become unacceptable for many. Why is there that difference?
Irish nationalism was and is anti-imperialist but Israeli nationalism is - wrongly I think - seen as itself imperialist. Israeli nationalism is to some extent a response to anti-Jewish sentiment.
........
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The English are also a people with a right to self-determination - and not just to a football team.
-------------------
I am basically an anti-imperialist anarchist.
is this an "Inappropriate Comment"? -
"I don't debate [with] Israelis", George Galloway.
Ahem.
Israelis are humans.
This comment is absurd. You may as well have said
"I don't debate Uzbekistanis".
You could conceivably say "I don't debate PEOPLE who call themselves "Israelis"." Possibly.
Tho that is a bit silly too of course.
What he objects to is the State of Israel - as do some Jews.
But what he said sounded - let's say - silly.
I hope good old George - who I like a great deal - has the guts to withdraw that comment made in an understandable moment of stupidity.
Possibly similar to the attention-grabbing stupid comment regarding raping sleeping women or whatever it was.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the Jews are a people with a right to SELF-DETERMINATION.
It is slightly annoying - let's say - that the EU and people from Europe in general tell Israel what do to - the representatives of a continent that nearly destroyed the Jewish people.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RE: TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
Good lefty saintly Irish and Scots folk like Galloway, some people at the UN, The Hallidays (Denis and Fred R.I.P.), Sine'ad O'Connor - saint that she is, Sea'n McBride R.I.P. USUALLY criticize (the State of) Israel for things like the Palestinian Nakbah, massacres, settlements, wars etc. Fair enough.
What annoys me is that they are often ALSO Irish Republicans. After all, Ireland is a republic.
The POINT is IRISH REPUBLICANISM obviously involves the concept in some way of TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY.
And yet this is forgotten and goes out of the window when it comes to Israel - where territorial integrity is probably a PRACTICAL NECESSITY apart from many other factors!
It SEEMS like pure hyprocrisy!
To pinpoint further my meaning - they seem to be saying something like :
The "Irish" have a right to the whole of "Ireland" BUT "the Jews" don't have a right to the whole of "Israel".
===================================================
I saw the monument below in Dublin almost exactly 20 years ago in about April 1993.
Among other things, I thought "Wow! That's a bit pro-IRA!"
Yet of course the man who composed the words did so decades before the IRA came into existence.
..................................................
In the case of Ireland the statement below is often regarded as wholly laudable.
Perhaps one reason being Ireland's suffering from imperialism.
In the case of Israel, perhaps they would not be regarded with the same approval were they about the Jewish people.
One reason is ignorance. Because it could perhaps be understandably believed that the words below apply a fortiori to the Jews.
My reaction to this monument at the age of 20 was on balance positive as I saw this as a question of justice and self-determination. It also is about uniting the people as equals rather than any territory.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Still it should cause us to pause and think again about the quasi-religion of nationalism.
Can you have "good nationalism" and "bad nationalism"?....
The words mention Ireland only once. If you are any kind of nationalist, apply them to your "Nation" by replacing its name with "Ireland" and then see how you feel about it. Very interesting anyway!
For example replace the word "Ireland's" with the word "Israel's" and for some reason the quote would suddenly become unacceptable for many. Why is there that difference?
Irish nationalism was and is anti-imperialist but Israeli nationalism is - wrongly I think - seen as itself imperialist. Israeli nationalism is to some extent a response to anti-Jewish sentiment.
........
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The English are also a people with a right to self-determination - and not just to a football team.
-------------------
I am basically an anti-imperialist anarchist.
