In what ways is Psychiatry like Nazism?
It involves the arbitrary and compulsory detention of humans by the state in concentration camps without justification;
it involves arbitrarily categorising and stigmatizing whole groups of humans as defective and subhuman;
it involves arbitrarily and unjustifiably categorizing people as "sick"; it involves the compulsory torture, poisoning and
electrocuting of humans without the slightest justification. Ultimately it is a form of mass murder. All of this on a large and worldwide scale.
Like Nazism in its time all of these crimes are currently committed within the law - though they all breach human rights law.
For reasons like this and for other reasons it is more than acceptable to compare Psychiatry to Nazism and to equate Psychiatry with Nazism - and that's why I do so.
If someone commits a crime then that is a matter for the law and for penology. Medicine and Penology should be kept entirely separate. They are increasingly blurred. The only circumstances in which the state has the right to detain anyone is if they have committed a crime and been found guilty of it by a just tribunal. This principle is very old in England going right back to Magna Carta at least. It is compromised by Psychiatry. If we break this principle - which Psychiaty does - then we have an aspect of Nazism - arbitrary detention by the state. We gave our life blood to defeat Nazism and we only just won.
Allowing Nazism to exist in our society insults every soldier that died for our freedom
"The distinguishing feature of the libertarian view is the belief that self-ownership is a right and initiating violence is a fundamental wrong. Psychiatric practice is based on the belief that self-ownership is a medical wrong, and that initiating violence is a medical right." Thomas Szasz.
I am not saying that I was simply a victim of a miscarriage of "psychiatric justice". I am saying that there is simply no such thing as "psychiatric justice." So-called "Preventitive Detention" - the basis of psychiatry - is itself a wicked crime and an injustice.
Most judges would admit that this is undeniable.
It involves the arbitrary and compulsory detention of humans by the state in concentration camps without justification;
it involves arbitrarily categorising and stigmatizing whole groups of humans as defective and subhuman;
it involves arbitrarily and unjustifiably categorizing people as "sick"; it involves the compulsory torture, poisoning and
electrocuting of humans without the slightest justification. Ultimately it is a form of mass murder. All of this on a large and worldwide scale.
Like Nazism in its time all of these crimes are currently committed within the law - though they all breach human rights law.
For reasons like this and for other reasons it is more than acceptable to compare Psychiatry to Nazism and to equate Psychiatry with Nazism - and that's why I do so.
If someone commits a crime then that is a matter for the law and for penology. Medicine and Penology should be kept entirely separate. They are increasingly blurred. The only circumstances in which the state has the right to detain anyone is if they have committed a crime and been found guilty of it by a just tribunal. This principle is very old in England going right back to Magna Carta at least. It is compromised by Psychiatry. If we break this principle - which Psychiaty does - then we have an aspect of Nazism - arbitrary detention by the state. We gave our life blood to defeat Nazism and we only just won.
Allowing Nazism to exist in our society insults every soldier that died for our freedom
"The distinguishing feature of the libertarian view is the belief that self-ownership is a right and initiating violence is a fundamental wrong. Psychiatric practice is based on the belief that self-ownership is a medical wrong, and that initiating violence is a medical right." Thomas Szasz.
I am not saying that I was simply a victim of a miscarriage of "psychiatric justice". I am saying that there is simply no such thing as "psychiatric justice." So-called "Preventitive Detention" - the basis of psychiatry - is itself a wicked crime and an injustice.
Most judges would admit that this is undeniable.