20 Dec 2018

"Insane", "mad", "crazy"

"Insanity", "craziness" and "madness" are concepts that have no scientific meaning.

"Insanity, craziness, or madness is a spectrum of both group and individual behaviors characterized by certain abnormal mental or behavioral patterns." (Source: wikipedia.)

There is no scientific basis for defining a behaviour as "abnormal".

It is only ever the opinion of the speaker.

For example, I think it is wrong and insane and crazy to lock people up if they have committed no crime.

Whereas this principle - that people can and should be locked up without their having committed a crime - is the very basis of Psychiatry. Shrinks would no doubt regard my views as "insane".

All we can ever mean when we call something "crazy", "insane" or "mad" is that we disagree with it or disapprove of it.

We may be justified in disapproving of it, but it has no scientific meaning to call it "crazy".

I think Psychiatry is wrong, immoral and intolerable.

I could also call it crazy and insane but I realize this has no scientific meaning and can't have.

..........

The imputation of a physical brain disease to someone on account of their thought or behaviour is simply an insult and a speculation.

If someone does have a physical brain disease then this does have a scientific meaning of course.
But this has nothing whatsoever to do with their behaviour or thinking in itself.

Judgements about behaviour or thinking are not scientific judgements.