3 Oct 2017

John Stuart Mill and Brexit.

"John Stuart Mill teaches us that democracy is not a dictatorship of the majority and certainly not on fundamental issues, on issues of vital interest, national interest - and I think membership of the European Union is a vital national issue and interest."

Guy Verhofstadt, pro-EU Belgian politician, talking about the Brexit Referendum result.

I voted for withdrawal from the European Union for precisely this reason - to avoid the undemocratic tyranny of the majority that the E.U. has represented.
The Greek people and state - for example - experienced the full force of this undemocratic tyranny of the majority.

It is nearly impossible to believe that Verhofstadt could be unaware of the irony of invoking John Stuart Mill in defence of the E.U.

But I think that Verhofstadt has missed something very obvious.
It was not on questions of national policy that Mill decried the tyranny of the majority but on questions of individual freedom.
John Stuart Mill believed in freedom and individual liberty. Mill saw the defence of individual rights as an antidote to the tyranny of the majority. 
As currently conceived the E.U. represents a tyranny of the majority - and in some senses not even that. A tyranny of the eurocrats is more accurate. The democratic rights of smaller countries are not adequately defended.
Until the E.U. truly believes in freedom and democracy rather than tyranny, Verhofstadt's words must ring very hollow and are painfully ironic.

It was with the aim of maximizing individual liberty that I voted for Brexit. Not in any way because I am an extreme English or British nationalist.
It was also as a defence of a very liberal English nationalism, to counter the anti-democratic and tyrannical E.U. and the railroading of E.U. policy.
John Stuart Mill is also seen as a defender of such moderate liberal nationalism.
I am not a nationalist, I am an internationalist and I am in favour of supranational co-operation.

I simply believe that the E.U. has not acted in a democratic way, and is patently an example in action - as currently conceived - of the tyranny of the majority that J.S.Mill warned us about so long ago.