19 Oct 2013

Gilbert Ryle. "CATEGORY ERROR"


 Gilbert Ryle

"CATEGORY ERROR"...

This is a good frase from the works of the English filosofer Gilbert Ryle that for me
serves to point out quite simply what it is I am often dealing with -
an error of category.

Something as simple as that.

For example - a "mental illness" simply cannot be. It is a "CATEGORY ERROR".

Paradoxically enuff the great thinker - a logical positivist - used this frase - I think - in discussion of the impossibility of a soul; in his book "The Concept of Mind" (1949).......

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

An example of what I would call a "CATEGORY ERROR":

"PSYCHO" + "PATHOLOGY"

The combination of these two elements into one concept is here impossible.
This results in a BANKRUPT CONCEPT.

The concept can be seen to be BANKRUPT anyway.

The linguistic combination is not necessarily the cause of the INADMISSABLE CONCEPT.
The language certainly reflects it.

..........