For all you theologists out there.... Dawkins compares your discipline to "Fairyology"!. Fair comment!
Narnia may exist..... but on your own terms, Theologists, HELL simply cannot.
I have left the Catholic Church a million times in my soul and mind on this point alone.
I have now left it permamently.
I tore up my Catholic Prayer Book and threw it in the Bin with ferocity on this point alone.
If one thinks about it LOGICALLY AND CLEARLY there SIMPLY CANNOT be a God-created nor God-ordained nor God-inflicted nor God-sustained nor God-anything place of eternal suffering.
And probably not even temporary.
It is a truly wicked human accretion in terms of Christian theology.
Embodying human revenge psychology.
Anglicans are FAR ahead of Catholics on this point.
Catholics pride themselves on doctrine. The church made this belief into one around the time of Dante.
As a doctrine it is intolerably evil and must be ended.
If you insist on it as a DOCTRINE - it is a doctrine that I insist I MUST utterly refuse to give even the merest assent to.
CAPITE? SPERO DI SI, SINCERAMENTE.
If Hell is a "stick" and Heaven a "carrot" - Hell is a stick that is against every convention of warfare known to man!
VERITATIS SPLENDOR:
"ANY institution of whatever kind that for whatever reason holds out to ANY being the prospect of and teaches the reality of a place of eternal suffering as a definitive, genuine and serious teaching is simply immoral."
Even if done at present in a half-hearted, friendly, evuncular way.
Sorry! But I can't be there. And it's a scandal that anyone is at present.
I mean these priests aren't well paid and aren't all Professors of Philosophy;
HOWEVER you'd think that they would baulk at being part of something that has that line in it - after all they do have all day long after Mass in the Parochial House to consider things.
And one can't help noting that a few of the pedophile priests "on the run in Marbella" etc. may be relieved to hear that - at least in my humble view - Hell cannot exist!
Judaism - if it insists upon a doctrine on this question - has for example the formulation of Maimonides - who taught that there was a RETRIBUTION beyond this world - a setting right - but in no way a permanent substantial place of eternal suffering.
I found out that about 1000 years ago Official Catholic Doctrine - thanks to Saint Augustine - was that ANY child who died unbaptised - even if they had done nothing more than pick their nose - would suffer hell forever.
In those days people really believed things like that too!
What an immoral teaching!
So it was worse then!
I no longer believe in reforming the Roman Catholic Church but in simply ending it.
---------------------------------------------------------
"I do not myself that any person who is really profoundly humane can believe in everlasting punishment."
Bertrand Russell in "Why I Am Not A Christian".