24 Jun 2012

"Sociobiology" is nonsense

I find "Sociobiology" to be an objectionable piece of language in itself. Almost as much and for similar reasons as the simply criminal conflation "Psychopathology."

What exactly is added by this conflation? Is it warranted by science or logic?
Once again the results of this kind of basic conceptual error are possibly damaging.

For example - one can conceivably and conceptually have "societies" of inanimate objects - like cars or buckets.

Obviously, more usually humans have societies - "society" referring principally to a CONCEPT.

"Society" is about relationship and membership generally speaking.

This is studied in the discipline "Sociology".

Humans are only ONE species of biological life.

Surely "Sociobiology" hence implies only HUMANS have "societies" ?....
It's inventor I think believes the opposite?... seeing Ants as having "societies" of a kind?....

The piece of language "Sociobiology" may possibly in itself facilitate seeing SOCIAL difference as more related to biology than may be the case etc. etc. etc.....

Someone unaware of an official definition may surmise that its meaning would be something like:

"the scientific study of biological life ...with reference to and specifically concerning its relationship to (human?) society"...?....

Biology is of course a (NATURAL) SCIENCE.... whereas "Sociology" is a part of the HUMANITIES and a "Social Science".....

Here they seem to have been forced into a "shotgun marriage"?

--------------------------------------

I have this morning "wiki-ed" the offending idomatic concoction - "Sociobiology". To wit:-

"Sociobiology is a field of scientific study which is based on the assumption that social behaviour has resulted from evolution and attempts to explain and examine social behavior within that context."

[One assumes this is only referring to Homo Sapiens - one biological species amongst many millions!...]

==============================================================

Note how the term "assumption" is used to define this new-fangled independent self-sufficient "science".

SURELY - "BIOSOCIOLOGY" would "fit the bill"? And be less misleading?.....

"Sociochemistry" would on such terms be equally valid. This would attempt to explain the behaviour of humans and other animals by their chemical composition.

Fair enough. :)
.........